If the new dog cannot do anything right
A beloved and trusted dog dies – and its successor, no matter how hard it tries, simply cannot do anything right? This happens frequently, especially with assistance dogs. Australian researchers have scientifically investigated this phenomenon.
A dog has died, a new one comes into the house, and this animal simply cannot measure up to its predecessor. This is particularly noticeable when, in addition to simply living together, a finely tuned interaction between owner and dog is crucial, as is the case with guide dogs and other assistance dogs. In international research, this phenomenon is known as “Successor Dog Syndrome. “
Several scientific studies already exist on guide dogs for people who are blind. A qualitative study from Australia has now also examined cases involving other assistance and companion dogs. A team of psychologists interviewed ten women with canine companions who exhibited the “second dog phenomenon.” The responses were analyzed for recurring patterns to uncover deeper meanings and experiences.
Fear of renewed loss:
All 10 study participants had a strong bond with their previous dog. For all of them, the grief over the previous dog persisted. Moreover, all described negative feelings towards their subsequent dog, even to the point of being unable to form a new bond at all.
A major reason for this seemed to be the constant comparison with their four-legged predecessor. Expectations were high, and understandably, the new animal could not immediately meet them. Some respondents worried about being physically or emotionally harmed by less harmonious interactions with the animal. For others, a lack of trust in the new animal led to a feeling of threat to their own independence, which the assistance dog was actually supposed to guarantee.
More Time for Grief:
The results of this study, published in the journal “Anthrozoös,” indicate that sufficient time is necessary to process the loss of a beloved pet. If a new dog moves in too quickly, the replacement is more likely to be rejected. Especially with assistance dogs, the period for grieving is often too short, as new animal support is quickly needed to manage daily life. Increased support from friends, family, or care services may help bridge the gap during this grieving period.